Date of Visit: March 7, 2005 (Monday)
Reservation for 9 at 7:30
Website: http://www.susur.com
BYOW corkage fee: $60
7-course tasting menu ($110)
Food
Amuse-bouche: fish fritter with chorizo
- Upscale version of fish sticks…..tasty but not memorable
Meat: lamb tenderloin, roasted vegetable (turnip, lotus root), fried taro dumpling, roasted pineapple, peanut sauce
- Perfectly pink lamb, not too gamey. Went well with satay peanut sauce
- Interesting choice (in a good way) of roasted vegetable. Roasting brought out the sweetness
- Taro dumpling is borrowed directly from dim sum menu. Chinese flavour salt in the batter added a nice punch. Okay but not excellent
- Roasted pineapple was so acidic it sent a nasty tingle to my tongue
- Individual items of the dish did not work together to enhance the entire dish
Salad: cold foie gras, shaved abalone, beef capaccio, baby spinach, grated parmesan
- Foie and abalone were both sliced paper thin….hard to taste the richness of either ingredient
- Although this dish was composed of all very rich and supposedly flavourful ingredients, it was strangely devoid of flavour….the only dominating flavour was the parmesan cheese
Palate Cleanser: blood orange gelee, blood orange segment, grapefruit segment, grapefruit juice, cracked black pepper
- Black pepper really highlighted the flavour of the citrus
- Gelee’s texture was a bit too tough. Tasted like it was made with agar agar instead of gelatin
- The glass dome that covered the plate was warm. A big no no.
Fish: pan fried striped bass, roasted artichoke, plum sauce, rose petals
- Rose petals were totally ornamental, did not enhance the dish at all
- Fish was cooked just right
- One of the best dish of the night
- Plum sauce was too subtle for my taste
Appetizer: lobster shrimp croquette, mango cold roll, wasabi mousse, ume sauce, tobiko
- Lobster and shrimp filling resembled the Chinese banquet dish fried crab claws. This filling was wrapped by thin julienne of potato and deep fried. The potato wrapping fell off when I cut into the dumpling. Interesting idea that did not work
- Mango cold roll has an exceptionally thick wrapping
- Wasabi mousse was tasty but the ume sauce lacks punch
Soup: hot and sour consommé, chicken and shrimp dumpling wrapped in watercress
- Very strong taste of vinegar. Imagine a hot and sour soup distilled to its flavour essence…. which was stock and vinegar.
- Dumpling was interesting
Dessert: earl grey crème brulee, mango raspberry sorbet Alaska, lemon tart, rose petals
- Crème brulee was tough and grainy
- Meringue on the sorbet was gummy
- Lemon tart was standard fare….nothing special
- Interestingly, there were four variations of dessert dishes served at our table instead of the usual two variations for all other courses. This led me to think that perhaps we were served leftovers from Saturday’s service…
Service
- Overall, I was unhappy with the service. I found the waiters very intrusive…every gesture was done with flamboyance and flair to announce their presence. Clearing the table, changing of cutlery, refilling our water glasses….I found the waiters ducking and getting in between the diners as if approaching an obstacle course. This distraction very much dampened my enjoyment of the dining experience because they made me feel as if I was in their way all the time.
- Since the menu only listed the course of the dishes, we depended on the waiters to tell us about each dish where they were served. Unfortunately, this was not done in the most satisfactory manner. The waiter chose to stand at one end of our long table and yelled out the components of the dish. However, because the dining room was quite noisy, I had trouble hearing what he said at all. For the palate cleanser course, our table was ignored for at least five minutes before a waiter came over to lift the dome off the plates and gave us a hurried description of the dish. No description was given for the dessert course at all.
- The water glasses for tap water were not refilled until we asked
- During the fish course, the dish for one of the diner at our table was served at a much later time than the others
- Incorrect cutlery were placed at the place-setting for some of the courses
Overall Impression
The poor service seriously affected my enjoyment of the meal. Some of the food demonstrated flashes of creativity but there were more misses than hits at this particular meal. The biggest disappointment though, was the fact I found most of the dishes were merely a composition of many components instead of creating a harmony that conveyed “sum is greater than its parts”. This is my second experience at Susur (my last visit was more than 3 years ago) but it was as lackluster, if not more, than my last visit.